Why HT made a difference in lead up to International Women's Day

International Women's Day is on 8th March
Instead of a distinguished panel choosing an appropriate candidate for HT Woman 2011 award (probably in a closed meeting room), the reputed English newspaper opened the process of nomination and selection to its readers (at least in UP state of India). There might be others who might have done better, but let me share this example I know of, how participation, representation and ownership is so key in this era powered by social media.

No Ifs About The Butts, No Matter How Much You Puff

One of the most powerful and cost-effective mediums to educate consumers about the hazards of smoking is the pictorial health warning on the package of tobacco products itself. It has universal reach, and the cost of package warnings is paid for by the tobacco companies, not the government. It is empirically established from the experiences of other countries that strong pictorial health warnings on tobacco products are powerful communication tools that can take the message of the health hazards of tobacco to the masses, including the illiterate. Health warnings on tobacco product packages are critical to any effective tobacco control strategy, as they deter non starters and motivate consumers to quit. Read more

Article 11 of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC – the global tobacco treaty to which India is a signatory) obligates its parties to ensure that tobacco products packages carry appropriate health warnings describing their harmful effects. According to Dr Samlee Plianbangchang, WHO Regional Director for Southeast Asia, "Tobacco is the only legally available product that kills people, and 1.2 million people die from tobacco use in our region annually. An effective tobacco control strategy is, therefore, not just a programmatic necessity but also a moral imperative."

The Cigarette and Other Tobacco Products Act, 2003, also mandates pictorial warnings on all tobacco products in India, with annual rotation of pictures/ photographs used in these graphic warnings.

Alas! The death peddling lobby of tobacco/ cigarette manufacturers seems to have a stronger hold on the Indian government, than the right to health of its millions. After many initial delays, India finally put out pictorial warnings on tobacco products from May 31, 2009. These proved to be very mild and hence ineffective. The hazy images of lungs and a scorpion's picture on gutkha and cigarette packets were ludicrously funny, and not scary, to say the least. As per its commitment to the FCTC, and its own obligations to implement domestic laws, the government agreed to replace them, with scarier pictures of cancer stricken mouths, by 1st June 2010. To the dismay of the anti-tobacco activists and all health conscious people, this date was then shifted to 1st December 2010, and now to December 2011.

Once again our democratic government has buckled under the pressure tactics of the tobacco industry. According to a news published recently (click on the link to read the news), a RTI query, filed by Voluntary Health Association of India (VHAI), has revealed that the new pictorial warnings on tobacco products were deferred due to pressure from the tobacco industry, including ITC and the Pan Shop Owners Association, which comprises retailers of cigarettes, bidis, chewing tobacco and betel leaf. The government has unashamedly 'admitted' that the new pictorial warnings on tobacco packs have been deferred because of the 'pressure' exerted by the industry and other interested parties. The RTI revealed that the tobacco lobby had also approached the Union Health and Family Welfare Minister of Government of India, Shri Ghulam Nabi Azad to delay the implementation. Union Law Minister Shri Veerappa Moily, received a letter from Paan Shops Owners Association of India dated, March 25, 2010, which said, "Due to graphic tobacco warnings, our retailers have seen a decline in the business of our members. About 60 to 70 per cent of the business of these shopkeepers comes from tobacco products, but the impact has been felt beyond just these products as customers are not visiting these outlets. We sincerely hope you will give due consideration to the voice of aam aadmi, that is to defer the introduction of the new health warnings."

The Health Ministry also admits to have received anti-pictorial warning representations from tobacco giants like the ITC and Tobacco Institute of India. One of them, from ITC and dated March 5, 2010 said: 'Rotation of designs every year is not worthwhile as any changes in the graphic elements of the tobacco packs will require substantial redesign of the packs which in turn would necessitate procuring of new printing cylinders and ancillary equipments for a large number of packs.'

Tobacco majors argued that they have large unsold stocks and must be allowed to expend these before the warnings are changed. They threatened to maintain the current halt on fresh production - a move that can impact the labour intensive industry including cultivators.

So the Cabinet not only took a decision on Dec 7 to further defer the pictorial warnings by a year, but the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, through a Gazette notification dated 20.12.2020, amended the Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products (Packaging and Labelling ) Rules 2008. For Rule 5 the following has been substituted --“Rotation of Specified Health Warnings—The Specified Heath Warning on tobacco packs shall be rotated every two years from the date of notification of the rules or earlier, as the case may be, as specified by the Central Government.”

It would be worth mentioning here that while Indian tobacco products warn consumers with hazy images of lungs and scorpion, other nations clearly depict the devastating impact of tobacco on a smoker’s health through graphic pictorial warnings. A picture from Uruguay shows a baby surrounded by cigarette-smoke rings, warnings from Thailand (it has implemented 9 different pictorial warnings on 50% surface area of cigarette packs) show pictures of a mutilated and cancer-affected mouth.
While Bangladesh has six different types of text warnings covering 30 percent surface area of all smoking tobacco products, Maldives has mandated five different types of textual warnings covering 30 percent surface of the cigarette package.

Even our next door neighbour Pakistan has introduced gory pictorial warnings on all tobacco packs from August 30 in a bid to deter consumers from smoking or chewing tobacco. It has made it mandatory for 40% of all tobacco packs — on both sides — to carry the image of a rotting mouth suffering from cancer along with a health warning.

On the contrary, India, where 2,500 people die daily due to use of tobacco, has put off the introduction of strong and gory pictorial warnings till December 2011. But there is a ray of hope from the judiciary, if not from the executive. Even as the government backed down under pressure, the Supreme Court recently banned plastic packaging for tobacco products. In a reference to the fight against cancer, the Apex Court said that unlike the government, it could not remain a mute spectator to the public health menace and asked the government to implement the order by March 2011, even if it "brings the entire tobacco industry to a standstill."

We can only hope (and fight) for better sense to prevail upon the rulers of our country, so that they do not barter the lives of millions for financial gains of a miniscule, yet powerful segment of society.


Shobha Shukla - CNS
(The author is the Editor of Citizen News Service (CNS) and also serves as the Director of CNS Diabetes Media Initiative (CNS-DMI).She is a J2J Fellow of National Press Foundation (NPF) USA. She has worked earlier with State Planning Institute, UP.  Email: shobha@citizen-news.org, website: www.citizen-news.org)  




Published in:
Citizen News Service (CNS), Thailand/India
News Blaze News, California, USA        
Elites TV News, USA 
Yahoobuzz.com
Redditnews.com         
Twitter.com   
Topics News, India                    
 

Support the doctor of the adivasis

Christmas wasn't merry...
2011 will be unhappy
until Dr. Binayak Sen is free!
Some of us were fortunate to spend a few hours with this soft spoken civil liberties activist sometime back. His humility was touching and inspiring. It is extremely painful that an insecure state has imprisoned him again on irrational grounds. We hope that this humane spirit will return to remote parts of rural Chattisgarh to continue working for the benefit of some of the most excluded Indians through his organization, Rupantar, soon. Read more




Please express your solidarity with the campaign to release him in one or more of the ways below:

a. Signing the petition to the President of India: "Indian Justice Has Failed Dr Binayak Sen"

b. Following the posts on:

Free Binayak Sen Campaign
Facebook - FREE DR BINAYAK SEN CAMPAIGN
Twitter - @binayaksen

c. Joining or organizing protests (online and/or offline) against the ludicrous judgement and unnecessary life sentence

d. Blogging (text or audio/visual), talking, texting, tweeting, writing (poems, opinions, comments), spreading awareness in support of the critical action to secure Dr. Sen's freedom

e. Any other manner - please share your relevant word(s) and deed(s) via Facebook and Twitter

Published in:
Elites TV News, USA
Citizen News Service (CNS), India/Thailand
Thetvrealist.com  
Redditnews.com                                                     

Palestinian leaders receive the Caravan in Damascus

Before leaving Diyarbakir on 19th December, 2010, for the last stop-over in Turkey, Gaziantep, the Asia to Gaza Solidarity Caravan visited the grave of Ali Haydar Bengi, the local man who got killed in the Israeli attack on flotilla from Turkey on 31 May, 2010, in international waters of Mediterrean Sea. His is one among the many graves with flowers planted on top in the graveyard but Bengi is now considered a proud martyr in Turkey as well as among Kurds. The members of caravan stood in silence for some moments at his grave. Read more


Like all meetings in Turkey the one in Gaziantep was also organized in a sports complex. A student of Jamia Millia Islamia of New Delhi, Aslam Khan, said in his speech that supporting the cause of Palestine is important because success here will mean a setback to the march of imperialism globally.

The members of caravan were promised that they would be given Syrian visa on arrival. The process was smooth. The visa fees for 81 members from 9 countries was waived. The members waited in their buses as exit stamp was placed on their passports on Turkey side and visa was issued on the Syrian side at Eajaz. They changed into waiting buses from hosts in Syria. The Governor of Alappo province, Ali Ahmed Mansoora, was there to receive the caravan at the border. Five roadside receptions, including at Edlip and Homs, were given on the way to Damascus by people who came out with Syrian and Palestinian flags and hand written placards. Some of there were spontaneous.

The Red Crescent of Iran has decided to donate USD 7,00,000 worth of medicines to be sent with this caravan. With the money donated for ambulances and medical-surgical equipments by the Iranian parliament the total contribution from Iran alone as aid to Gaza has reached USD 1 million now.
Charitable Association for Palestinian Relief hosted a meeting for the caravan on 21st December in Damascus. Ahmad Abdul Karim, on behalf of this organization as well as a member of Baath Party in Syria, assured his full support to the Asian caravan. Palestinian leaders Ramzam Abdullah of Islamic Jihad Movement in Palestine and Ahmad Jibril Abu Jehad, of leftist orientation, also spoke on the occasion.

Another high point of the caravan was meeting on 22nd December in Damascus which was addressed by Khalid Meshal, Head of the Political Affairs of Hamas, the group in power in Gaza. Khalid Meshal paid his tributes to Mahatma Gandhi for his inspiring struggle against the colonialism. He thanked the caravan, especially the two families - an Indian and a Pakistani - who were accompanying it as well as the families of caravan members who couldn't come for their support. He said he was happy to receive the caravan in Damascus and hoped that one day he will receive them in liberated Gaza and finally in liberated Palestine at Jerusalem.

Khalid Meshal made is clear that Palestinians are fighting for a real state without any occupation and with Jerusalem as its capital. All mosques and churches, including the Al Aqsa mosque, will be free in this Palestine and Jews, Muslims and Christians will live together as equal citizens. At the end of the meeting the Indian organizer Feroze Mithiborwala presented him a copy of Mahatma Gandhi's autobiography.

In an interview later in response to a question on Indian government's changing stand vis-a-vis Israel he said India, as an ancient civilisation, has had a traditional relationship with Arab world and it too had to fight against the imperialist power, hence it would do well to reflect on its position. In reponse to another question as to why, unlike Yasser Arafat, he was not reaching out to the world and especially to India, Khalid Meshal said he would be happy to come to India if invited. It is noteworhty that Brazil had recognized Palestine as a state just the previous day.

In the evening the caravan members were invited by Khaled Abed Al-Majeed, General Secretary of the Palestinian Popular Struggle Front, to visit the refugees in Yarmouk camp where close to one lakh people live. Damascus is home to about 5 to 6 lakhs Palestinian refugees.

On 23rd December, some members of the caravan were invited to Beirut where they met the former Prime Minister of Lebanon and now the President of International Committee to Break the Siege of Gaza, Dr. Salim Hoss. In an informal chat, at his apartment on the 6th floor of a building in the heart of city, he said one should be prepared for the worst from Israel which commits barbaric acts in the name of self defence whereas it is actually the Arab nations which have to worry about their self defence against Israel. He admitted that Lebanon has been the victim of Israeli aggression often but lately because of facing stiff resistance Israel has become careful. He said that Palestinian refugees in Lebanon, numbering about 50,000 were quite well behaved even though the Lebanese government was not able to take complete care of them.

Former member of parliament, Osman Saad, welcomed the caravan in Saida, capital of South Lebanon, the next day after which it was taken to the hilltop war museum at Mleeta, centre of valliant resistance against the Israeli occupation of Lebanon. Beginning with the first attack on Lebanon in 1975, Beirut was invaded in 1982, the second Arab capital to fall to Israel after Jerusalem in 1948. It tool 15 years of struggle before Israel partially withdrew from Saida and villages surrounding Mleeta in 2000 before its conclusive defeat in 2006. While the South Lebanon Army was fighting along with the Israeli forces it was Hizbullah which emerged as the saviour of Lebanese society.

The caravan which has now grown to 164 members - 60 from India, 32 from Jordan, 20 from Iran, 13 from Indonesia, 10 from Lebanon, 9 from Pakistan, 6 from Turkey, 4 from Bahrain, 3 from Malaysia, 2 each from Japan and Bangladesh and 1 each from Syria, Azerbaijan and Tajikistan - is now awaiting the clearance from Egyptian authorities to leave the shores of Syria to sail to Egypt before its final entry into Gaza.

(Dr Sandeep Pandey is a Ramon Magsaysay Awardee (2002) for emergent leadership, who is a part of the Asia to Gaza peace delegation. He is a member of National Presidium, People's Politics Front (PPF), heads the National Alliance of People's Movements (NAPM) and did his PhD from University of California, Berkeley, USA. He taught at Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kanpur before devoting his life to strengthening people's movements in early 1990s. He can be contacted at: ashaashram@yahoo.com. Website: www.citizen-news.org ) 

Published in:
Citizen News Service (CNS), India/Thailand 
Scoop News, New Zealand  
Now Public News, India     
Modern Ghana News, Accra, Ghana    
Elites TV News, California, USA     
Topixnews.com   
Allheadlinenews, India 
Florida Today News, Florida     
Crescent City News, California, USA
Big Soccer News, New Zealand 
Africa Live News, Africa 
Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS) 
Silobreaker News, India
Octomedia News
Iplextra.indiatimes.com 
Redditnews.com        
Beforeitsnews.com                       

The Nicholas Factor

It is Christmas time once again. It is the season of rejoicing; of giving and receiving; of raising our hands in Thanksgiving. My earliest recollections of Christmas festivities are associated with the socks which, we as children (even in Hindu homes), would hang up somewhere (not by the fireside, as there would be none) on Christmas Eve for Father Christmas to fill up. We were always rewarded with sweets or a story book, or something similar, which was sometimes found tucked under our pillows next morning, if it did not fit inside our small socks. But then, we had small desires and these simple gifts made us immensely happy. Read more


It was only much later that I learnt that this custom of hanging up a Christmas stocking originated from the story of Bishop Nicholas on whom the Father Christmas legend is based. The story tells how a local nobleman had lost his fortune and was sadly unable to provide dowries for his three unmarried daughters. St. Nicholas decided to help in secret. He waited until it was night and crept through the chimney. He had three purses of gold coins with him. As he was looking for a place to keep this gift, he noticed the stockings of the three girls that were hung over the mantelpiece for drying, and so put one purse in each stocking. This led to the custom of children hanging stockings or putting out shoes, eagerly awaiting gifts from Santa Claus or Father Christmas.

Another remembrance is of the scene of Nativity, which is still enacted in many missionary schools/churches. That also had a gift component of the three wise men bringing presents of myrrh and incense for the infant Jesus. But it seems that now the humble manger, with the infant Jesus swathed in rags, is almost forgotten. And so are the humble stockings.

We, the modern day parents, sow the seeds of ambition in our children right from infancy. We teach them to think big and act smart in order to become rich and powerful. So their wish list does not fit in a stocking, and really stretches the purse strings of Santa. The more expensive and exclusive the gift, the higher is their happiness quotient. Need has now been overshadowed with greed.  It is not only the children, but even we adults have such skewed up notions about giving and receiving. The other day I was invited to the 1st birthday party of an acquaintance’s grandchild. All of us invitees were trying to outdo the other, carrying loads of gifts for a kid who was literally born with a silver (nay gold) spoon. To my surprise I found that most of the guests, at this supposedly kids’ party, were either business friends or high government officials. Even in such a high profile setting, differential treatment to the guests (depending upon their profit value) was more than obvious. One trio of father, mother and daughter was being particularly pampered by the host. The catering waiters were instructed to take special care of this special guest, who turned out to be some bigwig from the income tax department. Liquor was flowing openly for the men folk (and rather discreetly for the women). The soulful renditions of the hired ghazal singer were drowned in the din of noises. This did not look to me like a children’s party from any angle. It was pathetically amusing that neither the ambience, nor the few kids present there, gave it the feel of someone’s 1st birthday party. But then, perhaps I was being just too stupid and naive. Someone wisely whispered in my ears that such parties are held to enhance the business prospects of the host family—birthdays are just an acceptable excuse. The giving of gifts and partaking of the hosts’ generosity are actually part of the profit generating business strategies, and also an opportunity to show off one’s opulence and social status.

It is a sad commentary on our morality that the noble gesture of giving and receiving is now dictated by social and financial obligations to further our monetary interests. The size and cost of our gift is not dependent upon the needs of the receiver. It depends upon what we hope to gain (other than gratitude) from giving it. The worth of our presents is almost invariably inversely proportional to the economic status of the recipient. Why else do we give cheaper gifts to those who are below our own social/economic status?

If only, our giving could be gentle as silence (as goes one of the hymns I learnt in childhood), and if it keeps in mind the needs of the receiver (and not the greed of the giver), then we will be really blessed. Only if we could inculcate the magnanimous modesty of Saint Nicholas while filling up empty stockings!

The birth of Christ is an event which teaches humanity the lessons of austerity and humility. It teaches us to respect the poorest of the poor and to accept the graces, as well as tribulations of life with equanimity. Let us not forget the real meaning of Christmas, which is of forgiveness and humility. Let us give with humility and receive with grace whatever is offered to us—not only by way of Christmas gifts, but in every sphere of our lives. Let us also not shower money on our children, but teach them to be humble and respectful, and imbibe in them a love for humanity. If we share our bounties with the indigent, our wealth is bound to multiply.

At this time of the Yuletide season let our faith be reaffirmed in the goodness of humankind, so that God is in Her place in heaven and all is right with the world.

May peace and goodwill always prevail on the earth.


Shobha Shukla - CNS
(The author is the Editor of Citizen News Service (CNS) and also serves as the Director of CNS Diabetes Media Initiative (CNS-DMI).She is a J2J Fellow of National Press Foundation (NPF) USA. She has worked earlier with State Planning Institute, UP.  Email: shobha@citizen-news.org, website: www.citizen-news.org) 

Published in:
Citizen News Service (CNS), India/Thailand  
Asian Tribune, Sri Lanka/Thailand  
Elites TV News, USA
Liberia News, Liberia
Ghana Nation News, Accra, Ghana
Now Public News, India  
All Voices News, India
PV Writer News, Mexico
Frank Macdonald News, UK
Bihar and Jharkhand News Service (BJNS)
Musicifi.com  
Twitter.com                                                                      

SAARC Countries To Collaborate In The Field Of Health Care

The 70th Annual conference of the Association of Surgeons of India ASICON 2010, held recently in New Delhi was one of the largest medical conferences of surgeons in the world. Over 7000 national and international delegates from India, England, Scotland, USA, Egypt and SAARC nations attended the conference. Read more

Panel discussions on surgical education, live telecasts of basic and advanced surgical procedures, and sessions on innovations in surgery were some interesting highlights of ASICON 2010. Critical evaluations, discussions and debates on surgery and surgical practices took place in a very vibrant atmosphere, leading to constructive and positive outcomes from this interactive and informative meet.

The panel discussion on “Reforms in Surgical Education, Training and Practice for 21st Century India” was indeed an intense affair, with valuable inputs and suggestions from stalwarts in the medical fraternity. According to Dr.NK Pandey, President, Association of Surgeons of India, “ Some very interesting topics in medicine and surgery such as robotic cancer surgery, reconstructive surgery, management of brain tumours, laparoscopic procedures, pancreas transplantation, SILS (Single Incision laparoscopic surgery), NOTES (Natural Orifice Transluminal  Endoscopic Surgery),and many more such innovations in surgery were discussed through lectures, orations, and presentation of case studies, by various stalwarts in the world of medicine from India and across the globe.”

 Another very interesting session was” Innovations in Surgery” (or practice of what is colloquially called Jugaad in Hindi), where different innovations for modifying surgical instruments were discussed. Surgeons have modified surgical instruments to lower the cost of surgeries. Dr.R.K Karwasra, Head of Surgery & Surgical Oncology, PGIMS, Rohtak, explained close suction technique for NGA (Naso Gastric Aspiration). In this technique the harmful secretions from the stomach are removed by aspirating it through the nasal orifice, with the help of a nasogastric tube. This method does not require precious nursing time, and is more hassle –free and convenient to use.

The SAARC symposium, aptly titled Back to Basics, saw an active participation of the medical fraternity from Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Nepal & Bhutan. It helped in ushering a deeper understanding of basic issues in surgical education, surgical training and surgical services daunting SAARC countries. It also opened the doors for more collaborative opportunities in healthcare between India and other SAARC nations. Dr.Narender Pinto of Sri Lanka hoped that such exchanges between India and other SAARC countries in the field of medical education and sharing of expertise in surgical practices among the surgeon fraternity would continue in the years to come.

 The climate of debate/discussion highlighting emerging trends in surgery, and live telecasts of basic/ advanced surgical techniques at the conference proved to be a tremendous experience even for seasoned surgeons.  The exchange of ideas at the conference is bound to enhance surgical acumen among doctors, and will go a long way in advancing the cause of surgery.

Shobha Shukla - CNS 


Published in:         
Citizen News Service (CNS), India/Thailand 
Elites TV News, USA                                                                                 

Kurdish Turkey gives warm welcome to Gaza Caravan

The first Asia to Gaza solidarity caravan reached Tibriz from Tehran (Iran) on 13th December, 2010. On the way the people of Zanjan welcomed the caravan and offered lunch. The mayor of Tibriz, Alireza Novin, hosted the caravan. The member of the caravan from Republic of Azerbaijan, Hakim Alijade, was the most popular with the crowd as he spoke in Turkish which is a popular language in this region of Iran. Infact, Tibriz falls in the East Azerbaijan province of Iran. Upon reaching Tibriz and two days before crossing over into Turkey the caravan was greeted by the morale boosting news that seven members of parliament of Iran have decided to join the caravan to Gaza. Read more


The second largest contingent, after India, of 13 members in this caravan is from Indonesia. Irman Abdurehman from this group informed the audience at the meeting in Tibriz that a voluntary organization Mer-C is planning to build a 100 bed trauma centre and rehabilitation hospital in Gaza. Immediately after the 22 days brutal attack started on Gaza two years ago, in which 1366 people, half of whom were women, children and elderly, died, a team from Indonesia set off for Gaza on 1st January, 2009, and signed a MoU with the Palestinian health minister to set up this hospital here. The Palestinian government provided a 1.5 hectares waqf land for this purpose and the Indonesian government backed this effort by readily agreeing to contribute Rupiahs 10 billion, approximately equivalent to US $ 1 million, towards construction of this hospital. Mer-C has raised another Rp 13 billion. The Indonesians have decided to have a long term association with the people of Gaza and share their suffering by continuing to serve them.

Bazargaan was the last stop-over inside Iran before the caravan moved into Turkey. Insani Yardim Vakfi or IHH was the host organization here which is a big Islamic charity operating in 125 countries. More importantly, it was IHH which had organized the aid flotilla to Gaza which was attacked by Israel on 31 May, 2010, in which 9 people, Ibrahim Bilgen, Ali Haydar Bengi, Cengiz Songur, Cengiz Akyuz, Cevdet Kiliclar - a journalist shot from close range into forehead, Getin Topcuoglu - who beathed his last in his wife's arms on the ship, Fahri Yildiz, Furkan Dogan - 19 years old, and Necdet Yildirim died and one, Ugur Suleyman Sonmez, is still in coma. This single incident has changed the equation between Israel and Turkey. There is attempt by Israel and US to label IHH as a terrorist organization and IHH is taking legal action against Israel in order to identify the war criminals and prosecute them.

The caravan was taken to its first stop Van in the form of a convey of vehicles. Several roadside receptions were organized on the way. In the public meeting held in a sports complex a speaker from the each of the countries represented in caravan Bahrain, Indonesia, Malaysia, Azerbaijan, Iran, Pakistan, Japan and India spoke. Advocate Gulden Sonmez and her colleague Nalan Dal who coordinated the meeting on behalf of IHH were both present on the ship Mavi Marmara, among the approximately 560 passengers, which bore the brunt of the Israeli attack on flotilla. Among other members present on the ship and who attended the meeting on 17th December, 2010, at Van were Abdulhalim Almali, Mehmet Gaken, Selahattin Ozer, Muhlis, Abdullah Camioglu, all from Turkey, and journalist Quassima Ibn Salah, of Moroccon origin. Among these Abdulhalim Almali was also wounded and is still recovering.

Later Gulden Sonmez shared with the caravan the preparations for the forthcoming event on 26th December, 2010, when the ship Mavi Marmara, having been released by Israel and repaired, except for the marks of attack, will return to Istanbul. Fifty thousand people from all over the world are likely to assemble to receive it. On 31 May, 2011, IHH is planning to organize a flotilla of fifty ships to the spot where the attack took place.

Israeli Prime Minister Banjamin Netanyahu has refused to apologize for the attack or pay compensation to the families of the deceased and injured. After UNHRC came up with an indicting report on the attack, another four member committee has been set up by the UN Secretary General with the objective of mediating between Israel and Turkey.

The next stop-over for the caravan was Diyarbakir, home of one of the martyrs of Mavi Marmara, Ali Haydar Bengi, after again being given several roadside receptions in cities falling on the way. The convoy had grown to about hundred vehicles on its second day in Turkey. In Diyarbakir police refused permission to hold an indoor meeting. People carrying placards with slogans in support of Gaza and Palestine and against Israel as well as photo of Ali Haydar Bengi, had lined the street. As a result a stree crossing meeting on an open truck was organized which was addressed among others by Fehmi Bulent Yildirim, the President of IHH, and the Indian organizer Feroze Mithiborwala. Mehmet Ali Zebec, from whoes body 9 bullets were taken out after the attack on Mavi Marmara, was present in the meeting in Diyarbakir. Hundreds of pigeons, symbols of peace, were released as a mark of commitment of the movement to liberate Gaza and Palestine.The route of the caravan passed through the Kurdish areas of Turkey, where there is a simmering movement for autonomy. IHH wanted to convey to the people that as the caravan composed of people of different religious and ethnic backgrounds, Turks and Kurds needed to live together in harmony. In fact, after the attack on Mavi Marmara people with different shades of opinions in Turkey have come together on the question of ending the siege of Gaza. As Yildirim mentioned in a press conference later, anybobdy who had a soft corner for Israel was disillusioned now.

Common people who came to public events of the caravan in Turkey wanted their pictures to be taken with the caravan members to express their emotions of solidarity. They warmly shook hands and hugged the visitors. The caravan has been able to provide a channel to the people's sentiments. Like in Iran, men, women and children came out on streets to support the caravan and send their greetings to Gaza.

 (Dr Sandeep Pandey is a Ramon Magsaysay Awardee (2002) for emergent leadership, who is a part of the Asia to Gaza peace delegation. He is a member of National Presidium, People's Politics Front (PPF), heads the National Alliance of People's Movements (NAPM) and did his PhD from University of California, Berkeley, USA. He taught at Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) Kanpur before devoting his life to strengthening people's movements in early 1990s. He can be contacted at: ashaashram@yahoo.com. Website: www.citizen-news.org ) 


Published in:
Citizen News Service (CNS), India/Thailand 
Elites TV News, New Delhi, Delhi 
Now Public News, India         
Topix News, Turkey 
Hurrypotttering.com      
Anti.semitism.net 
Octomedia.net 
Friendfeed.net  
Twitter.com    
Thetvrealist.com     
Musicifi.com 
Keegy News, India   
One News Page, India